Fans of the Tyneside club are progressively regarding Eddie Howe's outfit as an inconsistent companion. When everything clicks, they prove to be the ultimate thrill-seekers, delivering breathtaking displays. But, in other matches, key individuals like their midfield linchpin and others utterly do not show up.
Compounding this issue is a second-half strategy suffused by a worrying streak of disorganization. Before their holiday fixture to Old Trafford, the facts reveal a sobering tale: the team has squandered 13 precious Premier League leverage from leading positions this season and are yet to keep a shutout in ten consecutive matches in every tournament. Securing a win at their famous stadium would be only their second league triumph on the road this year.
In contrast, defeat has only come on one occasion in their most recent 6 league encounters, and despite occupying a seemingly lowly eleventh position, they remain a only 6 marks away from the coveted Champions League places. Consider an upcoming two-part Carabao Cup semi-final against Manchester City and a decent chance of moving on to the Champions League knockout phase, and it becomes simpler to understand the gaffer's guarded optimism.
“We don't just have problems,” stated the club's manager. “You can see assets as well. My glass is firmly positive right now. I realize outside observers could have a divergent take, but in my view we are improving.”
The question is: can this collection of players match – or even surpass – the successes of the previous campaign's cup glory and fifth-place standing? Juggling a hectic fixture list makes this difficult.
This heavy-leggedness could explain the inability to maintain a superb first-half showing versus their London rivals, ultimately letting slip a 2-0 lead to draw 2-2. Similarly, it could be the reason for a subdued performance in a painful defeat to local rivals Sunderland, where the team seemed lethargic just days after a demanding European excursion.
While coaching is clearly the manager's forte, the constant grind of two games a week matches has severely limited essential coaching hours. This impedes the team's tactical evolution to operating with summer signing their number nine leading the line, rather than the departed their former star. While immensely gifted, Woltemade does not possess the same electric breakaway speed or relentless defensive work rate.
In fact, the side's signature pressing game has occasionally failed. Injuries to crucial component Joelinton have been a factor, while big-money arrivals Anthony Elanga and the English midfielder have struggled adapting since their combined ÂŁ90m+ transfers.
If a move to a three-man defense could theoretically help the team, a full-blown backline injury crisis renders that unlikely. First-choice full-backs will be absent for the next key matches, further testing the squad's resilience.
When playing at their energetic best, they seem virtually unplayable. The issue is sustaining that level for the entire 90 minutes. The typical plan B of dropping deep into a passive defensive shape has at times been self-destructive.
“The Chelsea match descended into anarchic at two-all,” conceded the manager. “However we were going for the victory. Our mentality is to always go out to win.”
What appears called for is a balanced approach – with superior ball retention, a midfield capable of dictating the pace, and a pragmatic willingness to occasionally accept a draw. However, a determination to challenge on every fronts is testing finite player options to their limit.
It may sound sacrilegious to some, but a more selective strategy in the cup competitions earlier could have eased the current schedule pile-up. With critical European and league matches on the horizon, the imperative to carefully prioritize is becoming increasingly clear.
The manager acknowledged the magnitude of the challenge remaining. “Being involved this club, the expectations are immense. Each game is critical. We have work to do in the Premier League. We are in the League Cup last four, we aim to go through in the Champions League and do well in the FA Cup.
“We're moving in the correct path, but we have plenty of work to do to become the regularly successful side we aspire to be. The ability to put winning runs has escaped us this season.
“The task is to hit those levels we know we're capable of. The internal belief is that the confidence we can achieve it is coming back. But now we have to show it. It's not all doom and gloom currently, but the next few weeks will shape a lot.”